A Staten Island judge has blocked New York City’s proposed tax on secondary homes, dealing a significant legal blow to the city’s efforts to implement the policy. The ruling comes after plaintiffs successfully challenged the measure’s rollout, raising questions about its future. Legal experts suggest the decision could delay or alter the tax’s enforcement, leaving property owners and officials awaiting further developments. The case highlights ongoing disputes over how cities can regulate vacation and investment properties.


New York City’s planned tax on secondary homes was dealt a major setback Tuesday after a Staten Island judge ruled in favor of the plaintiffs challenging the rollout.